Balancing the Liquidity Scales
-
bookmark
-
print
- Keywords:
- liquidity
- treasurers
- next gen treasury
For CFOs and corporate treasurers, the events of 2020 have highlighted the need for sound fundamentals. We’ve seen organizations boost their cash holdings, but that creates its own set of challenges in a low-yield environment.
I recently discussed the issue of how CFOs and treasurers can get the most out of their liquidity strategies with three experts:
-
Christina Boyle, Managing Director and Head, Corporate Banking Business Services, BMO Capital Markets
-
Jim Santoro, Managing Director, Liquidity Specialist, BMO Capital Markets
-
Grant Nicholson, Treasurer, IHS Markit, a provider of information, analytics and economic measures
Following is a summary of our conversation.
Cash Reserves Increase
As Boyle pointed out, corporate treasurers reacted immediately to the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic by increasing their cash reserves, though slightly less so than they did in 2009 in response to the credit crisis. For the most part, treasurers boost their cash holdings by:
-
Delaying investments in capital expenditures and discretionary projects
-
Moderating capital return activities like share repurchases or dividends
-
Raising cash from draws to bank source liquidity
But Boyle pointed out that the amount of liquidity available from bank sources fell for non-investment-grade firms, which drew on revolvers to source their cash. For investment-grade companies, on the other hand, the proportion of bank sources held steady, and even increased for those able to raise incremental 364-day facilities.
“The punchline here is that unless you're an investment-grade firm, the choices you make on bank credit facility size may portend your framing for your overall liquidity profile in the next crisis,” Boyle said.
Determining Your Liquidity Needs
Beyond shoring up cash reserves, it's critical to determine the right amount of liquidity for your organization in both typical and uncertain market conditions. There's no single formula that determines the exact amount of liquidity you need—company size, industry sector and other factors all play a role. That’s why determining the right amount of liquidity is as much art as it is science.
Market conditions also play a role. The Paycheck Protection Program in the U.S. and the Business Development Bank of Canada’s COVID-19 support programs added significant liquidity to the markets, leaving a lot of bank balance sheets well-funded, which in turn means bank deposit products are not offering attractive yields. But as Santoro said, it’s important to make sure that you're optimizing the returns on your cash and cash equivalents to generate revenue and maximize shareholder value.
Santoro and Nicholson pointed to three best practices to achieving this goal.
- Forecasting. Knowing how much cash you have on hand is crucial, Nicholson said. In his role, Nicholson focuses on two types of forecasting. The direct cash flow model, which tracks balance inflows and outflows. He said this approach works well for forecasting 90 days out. For forecasting beyond 90 days, Nicholson prefers an indirect method that includes net income and changes to the balance sheet, along with FP&A forecasts and strategic plans. “You have to collaborate across the organization— really tight efforts with accounting, finance teams, tax teams, etc.—to get that information,” he said.
Nicholson also noted that different companies will have different needs. Forecasting for a capex-intensive companies like a manufacturer, for example, will look different than it will for a data analytics firm.
- Differentiation. Not all cash is the same, and according to Santoro, this consideration is often overlooked when determining liquidity requirements. Knowing how to handle the three main buckets of cash—your operating, reserve and strategic capital—is a key to maximizing overall liquidity.“What we often see with a lot of companies is an outsized position in working capital cash, meaning the reserve and strategic buckets—where some of the cash should really live—is being shortchanged,” Santoro said. “The inability to best differentiate that type of cash often causes companies to forego opportunities for more higher yield-generating solutions than you may find against reserve and strategic cash.”
- A game plan. Once you have a handle on those three buckets of cash, Santoro said you can be in a position to capitalize on solutions optimized for each category. “Properly differentiating your types of cash can often generate 10, 20, 30 basis points, even in this environment, of additional yield. Making sure that you forecast it properly, have differentiated your buckets properly, and are identifying solutions—either bank deposit solutions or short-term liquidity solutions—that maximize yield will enable you to optimize the return you get on your cash and cash equivalents.”
Understanding Sticky Cash
Whereas Santoro outlined the three main buckets of cash reserves, Nicholson added a category he calls “sticky” cash.
“You could have cash that may take three months to get access to through some tax structuring activity or intercompany loan structure if you're a global company,” he said. “You really have to understand the types of cash that are on your balance sheet because during challenging times, it could be really difficult to access it in the near term.”
Nicholson also said treasurers need to be aware of how your working capital is being deployed. Some of it is often “trapped in the system.”
"It's liquid,” he said. “You can move it around, but you're constantly collecting or you're constantly paying out of certain receipts and disbursement accounts. You might have a lot of cash showing on your balance sheet, but it could be trapped on top of that amount. Let's say that's $10 million, and you need $30 million around the business. So you really need $40 million of liquidity, not $30 million.”
Secure Your Liquidity When You Don’t Need It
If 2020 has demonstrated anything, it’s that conditions can deteriorate quickly, so organizations and treasury departments need to be nimble. That’s why, as Boyle said, “The best time to address the bank liquidity need is when you don't need it.”
Nicholson agrees with that kind of proactive approach. "Treasurers don't typically get fired for having too much liquidity. If you wait, when you do need it, it may be harder to get because it's either a macro environment challenge, or even maybe a specific corporate challenge. So even if you can get it, it's also going to be extremely expensive at that time, so prepare ahead.”
Most of our clients and prospects felt the impact resulting from the pandemic. Our discussion was a good reminder that liquidity requires being disciplined around both preserving cash and generating returns.
As Boyle noted: “Change and uncertainty is inevitable, and financial decision makers are best served to maintain a liquidity plan for the next unplanned shock to the market.”
Oscar Johnson
U.S. Head of Commercial Sales for Treasury and Payment Solutions
312-461-8361
Oscar is the U.S. Head of Commercial Sales for Treasury and Payment Solutions for BMO Commercial Bank. His group is responsible for providing cash management, …(..)
View Full Profile >For CFOs and corporate treasurers, the events of 2020 have highlighted the need for sound fundamentals. We’ve seen organizations boost their cash holdings, but that creates its own set of challenges in a low-yield environment.
I recently discussed the issue of how CFOs and treasurers can get the most out of their liquidity strategies with three experts:
-
Christina Boyle, Managing Director and Head, Corporate Banking Business Services, BMO Capital Markets
-
Jim Santoro, Managing Director, Liquidity Specialist, BMO Capital Markets
-
Grant Nicholson, Treasurer, IHS Markit, a provider of information, analytics and economic measures
Following is a summary of our conversation.
Cash Reserves Increase
As Boyle pointed out, corporate treasurers reacted immediately to the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic by increasing their cash reserves, though slightly less so than they did in 2009 in response to the credit crisis. For the most part, treasurers boost their cash holdings by:
-
Delaying investments in capital expenditures and discretionary projects
-
Moderating capital return activities like share repurchases or dividends
-
Raising cash from draws to bank source liquidity
But Boyle pointed out that the amount of liquidity available from bank sources fell for non-investment-grade firms, which drew on revolvers to source their cash. For investment-grade companies, on the other hand, the proportion of bank sources held steady, and even increased for those able to raise incremental 364-day facilities.
“The punchline here is that unless you're an investment-grade firm, the choices you make on bank credit facility size may portend your framing for your overall liquidity profile in the next crisis,” Boyle said.
Determining Your Liquidity Needs
Beyond shoring up cash reserves, it's critical to determine the right amount of liquidity for your organization in both typical and uncertain market conditions. There's no single formula that determines the exact amount of liquidity you need—company size, industry sector and other factors all play a role. That’s why determining the right amount of liquidity is as much art as it is science.
Market conditions also play a role. The Paycheck Protection Program in the U.S. and the Business Development Bank of Canada’s COVID-19 support programs added significant liquidity to the markets, leaving a lot of bank balance sheets well-funded, which in turn means bank deposit products are not offering attractive yields. But as Santoro said, it’s important to make sure that you're optimizing the returns on your cash and cash equivalents to generate revenue and maximize shareholder value.
Santoro and Nicholson pointed to three best practices to achieving this goal.
- Forecasting. Knowing how much cash you have on hand is crucial, Nicholson said. In his role, Nicholson focuses on two types of forecasting. The direct cash flow model, which tracks balance inflows and outflows. He said this approach works well for forecasting 90 days out. For forecasting beyond 90 days, Nicholson prefers an indirect method that includes net income and changes to the balance sheet, along with FP&A forecasts and strategic plans. “You have to collaborate across the organization— really tight efforts with accounting, finance teams, tax teams, etc.—to get that information,” he said.
Nicholson also noted that different companies will have different needs. Forecasting for a capex-intensive companies like a manufacturer, for example, will look different than it will for a data analytics firm.
- Differentiation. Not all cash is the same, and according to Santoro, this consideration is often overlooked when determining liquidity requirements. Knowing how to handle the three main buckets of cash—your operating, reserve and strategic capital—is a key to maximizing overall liquidity.“What we often see with a lot of companies is an outsized position in working capital cash, meaning the reserve and strategic buckets—where some of the cash should really live—is being shortchanged,” Santoro said. “The inability to best differentiate that type of cash often causes companies to forego opportunities for more higher yield-generating solutions than you may find against reserve and strategic cash.”
- A game plan. Once you have a handle on those three buckets of cash, Santoro said you can be in a position to capitalize on solutions optimized for each category. “Properly differentiating your types of cash can often generate 10, 20, 30 basis points, even in this environment, of additional yield. Making sure that you forecast it properly, have differentiated your buckets properly, and are identifying solutions—either bank deposit solutions or short-term liquidity solutions—that maximize yield will enable you to optimize the return you get on your cash and cash equivalents.”
Understanding Sticky Cash
Whereas Santoro outlined the three main buckets of cash reserves, Nicholson added a category he calls “sticky” cash.
“You could have cash that may take three months to get access to through some tax structuring activity or intercompany loan structure if you're a global company,” he said. “You really have to understand the types of cash that are on your balance sheet because during challenging times, it could be really difficult to access it in the near term.”
Nicholson also said treasurers need to be aware of how your working capital is being deployed. Some of it is often “trapped in the system.”
"It's liquid,” he said. “You can move it around, but you're constantly collecting or you're constantly paying out of certain receipts and disbursement accounts. You might have a lot of cash showing on your balance sheet, but it could be trapped on top of that amount. Let's say that's $10 million, and you need $30 million around the business. So you really need $40 million of liquidity, not $30 million.”
Secure Your Liquidity When You Don’t Need It
If 2020 has demonstrated anything, it’s that conditions can deteriorate quickly, so organizations and treasury departments need to be nimble. That’s why, as Boyle said, “The best time to address the bank liquidity need is when you don't need it.”
Nicholson agrees with that kind of proactive approach. "Treasurers don't typically get fired for having too much liquidity. If you wait, when you do need it, it may be harder to get because it's either a macro environment challenge, or even maybe a specific corporate challenge. So even if you can get it, it's also going to be extremely expensive at that time, so prepare ahead.”
Most of our clients and prospects felt the impact resulting from the pandemic. Our discussion was a good reminder that liquidity requires being disciplined around both preserving cash and generating returns.
As Boyle noted: “Change and uncertainty is inevitable, and financial decision makers are best served to maintain a liquidity plan for the next unplanned shock to the market.”
What to Read Next.
COVID-19 and the Future of Treasury Departments
May 21, 2020 | Manage Cash Flow, Addressing Covid 19
The AFP survey “Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic” gathered responses from more than 400 corporate treasurers on how they’re rea…
Continue Reading>More Insights
Tell us three simple things to
customize your experience.
Contact Us
Banking products are subject to approval and are provided in the United States by BMO Bank N.A. Member FDIC. BMO Commercial Bank is a trade name used in the United States by BMO Bank N.A. Member FDIC. BMO Sponsor Finance is a trade name used by BMO Financial Corp. and its affiliates.
Please note important disclosures for content produced by BMO Capital Markets. BMO Capital Markets Regulatory | BMOCMC Fixed Income Commentary Disclosure | BMOCMC FICC Macro Strategy Commentary Disclosure | Research Disclosure Statements.
BMO Capital Markets is a trade name used by BMO Financial Group for the wholesale banking businesses of Bank of Montreal, BMO Bank N.A. (member FDIC), Bank of Montreal Europe p.l.c., and Bank of Montreal (China) Co. Ltd, the institutional broker dealer business of BMO Capital Markets Corp. (Member FINRA and SIPC) and the agency broker dealer business of Clearpool Execution Services, LLC (Member FINRA and SIPC) in the U.S. , and the institutional broker dealer businesses of BMO Nesbitt Burns Inc. (Member Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization and Member Canadian Investor Protection Fund) in Canada and Asia, Bank of Montreal Europe p.l.c. (authorised and regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland) in Europe and BMO Capital Markets Limited (authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority) in the UK and Australia and carbon credit origination, sustainability advisory services and environmental solutions provided by Bank of Montreal, BMO Radicle Inc., and Carbon Farmers Australia Pty Ltd. (ACN 136 799 221 AFSL 430135) in Australia. "Nesbitt Burns" is a registered trademark of BMO Nesbitt Burns Inc, used under license. "BMO Capital Markets" is a trademark of Bank of Montreal, used under license. "BMO (M-Bar roundel symbol)" is a registered trademark of Bank of Montreal, used under license.
® Registered trademark of Bank of Montreal in the United States, Canada and elsewhere.
™ Trademark of Bank of Montreal in the United States and Canada.
The material contained in articles posted on this website is intended as a general market commentary. The opinions, estimates and projections, if any, contained in these articles are those of the authors and may differ from those of other BMO Commercial Bank employees and affiliates. BMO Commercial Bank endeavors to ensure that the contents have been compiled or derived from sources that it believes to be reliable and which it believes contain information and opinions which are accurate and complete. However, the authors and BMO Commercial Bank take no responsibility for any errors or omissions and do not guarantee their accuracy or completeness. These articles are for informational purposes only.
This information is not intended to be tax or legal advice. This information cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding tax penalties that may be imposed on the taxpayer. This information is being used to support the promotion or marketing of the planning strategies discussed herein. BMO Bank N.A. and its affiliates do not provide legal or tax advice to clients. You should review your particular circumstances with your independent legal and tax advisors.
Third party web sites may have privacy and security policies different from BMO. Links to other web sites do not imply the endorsement or approval of such web sites. Please review the privacy and security policies of web sites reached through links from BMO web sites.
Notice to Customers
To help the government fight the funding of terrorism and money laundering activities, federal law (USA Patriot Act (Title III of Pub. L. 107 56 (signed into law October 26, 2001)) requires all financial organizations to obtain, verify and record information that identifies each person who opens an account. When you open an account, we will ask for your name, address, date of birth and other information that will allow us to identify you. We may also ask you to provide a copy of your driver's license or other identifying documents. For each business or entity that opens an account, we will ask for your name, address and other information that will allow us to identify the entity. We may also ask you to provide a copy of your certificate of incorporation (or similar document) or other identifying documents. The information you provide in this form may be used to perform a credit check and verify your identity by using internal sources and third-party vendors. If the requested information is not provided within 30 calendar days, the account will be subject to closure.