Commercial Real Estate Summer 2022 Market Update
-
bookmark
-
print
- Keywords:
- office
- multifamily
- industrial
- retail
As Bob Dylan famously sang, “The times they are a changin’.” But often in times of change, disruption and uncertainty, there can be space for new possibilities.
Where to begin? A global pandemic and the resulting variants; the war in Ukraine; high fuel prices; rising inflation, interest rates, bond yields, cap rates and construction costs; supply chain disruptions; housing affordability; labour shortages; recession fears; flagging consumer sentiment; working from home; the tangible impacts of climate change…. It’s a complex brew of issues, risks and challenges—and perhaps opportunities. But topping the list of concerns for CRE investors is inflation.
Inflation and cap rates
For the current generation of real estate professionals, inflation was just a theory, something to be studied in economics or history class, but hardly something to be concerned about. Then came the repeated economic hits from COVID-19, including supply chain issues; labour, goods and fuel shortages; and now, inevitably, inflation. As the world’s governments aggressively increase interest rates to contain surging inflation, the CRE industry finds itself navigating an unfamiliar landscape.
Inflation leads to higher bond yields, which reduces the risk premium for income producing CRE investments relative to risk-free investments like government bonds, putting upward pressure on cap rates and downward pressure on property values. Current indications from Altus Group suggest CRE investor yield expectations, which are expressed through cap rates, are indeed up approximately 15 bps over last quarter, implying a decline in property values of approximately 3%, and are expected to continue to climb through the remainder of 2022.1
Office and retail cap rates are expected to increase the most due to their typically longer leases, which limits those properties’ ability to increase rents to match inflation. While industrial properties typically have lease durations similar to office and retail, the incredible momentum of Canada’s industrial sector will likely see it continue to outperform the other asset classes and perhaps enjoy some further cap rate compression before levelling off or increasing in late 2022.
Multifamily properties are able to increase rents more frequently, typically annually. This allows multifamily rents to better pace inflation and is why multifamily properties are often described as a good (or at least a better) hedge for inflation. This ability to increase rents more frequently will likely see more modest cap rate increases in the multifamily sector relative to office and retail.
However, cap rates can be “sticky” and usually do not adjust quickly to changing market conditions. More often investment activity slows while buyers and sellers wait for the dust of change to settle. In the near term, expect to see a wider bid-ask spread. And just as residential sales are down 30% to 40% year over year, expect reduced CRE investment activity while the market waits to see if higher cap rates are a blip or the new normal.
Cash flow pressures
Inflation also puts pressure on property cash flows through higher interest rates on property debt and higher nonrecoverable property expenses. Inflation and rising interest rates also increase the likelihood of a recession, leading to additional pressure on property cash flow due to higher vacancies as business tenants delay growth plans or reduce their workforce.
For borrowers with upcoming term loan maturities, today’s higher interest rates can complicate those renewals. Most income producing term loans are sized to generate minimum debt service coverage, or DSC, of approximately 1.25x – a little less for multifamily properties. A $10 million commercial mortgage with a five-year term structured five years ago to generate 1.25x DSC at 3.5% interest and a 25-year amortization would today have an outstanding balance of about $8.6 million. Assuming the same property has a net operating income, or NOI, and a renewal rate of 5.5%, the property would today support a loan of only about $7.3 million to achieve 1.25x DSC at its remaining 20-year amortization, or about $8.2 million if re-amortized to 25 years, requiring a potential equity infusion or additional collateral of around $1.3 million at the remaining amortization, or approximately $400,000 at a 25-year amortization for the loan to renew.
For investors and developers, the rapid emergence of inflation and higher interest rates can challenge deals in flight that were baked with ageing ingredients. An acquisition that looked tasty when it was negotiated six months ago at a 5% cap rate that assumed 3.5% term financing is a lot less palatable if closing today with term debt closer to 5.5%. Likewise, construction of an income producing property that launched two years ago with 75% project financing might require an equity infusion to term-out the construction debt at today’s higher interest rates.
Opportunities ahead
Of course, change also ushers in opportunity. Some of today’s most successful CRE investors got their start capitalizing on the CRE market turbulence of the mid-1990s. Seldom-traded properties might become available as current owners opt to lock-in gains. Some property owners or developers might be receptive to a new partner to bolster their equity. And no doubt war chests are quietly being assembled to capitalize on potential distress situations should inflation remain high and interest rates continue to rise.
These are the times when prudent borrowers will be grateful for a good relationship with their banker. The few current CRE market participants who have lived through volatile times like this know that lenders want their customers to be successful. And that most of all, lenders (and their regulators) don’t like surprises. Lenders respond well to transparency and open communication. It’s best to engage your lender early if you see smoke on the horizon. Ignoring emerging challenges is seldom a good strategy.
Changing times indeed. If Bob Dylan were a CRE investor he might sum things up like this:
Come landlords and lenders throughout the land
And don’t disregard what you didn’t have planned
CRE’s fundamentals are beyond your command
If a deal you are arrangin’
Be careful that castle’s not built upon sand
For the times they are a changin’
1Altus Group
Jim Eplett
Head of Real Estate Private Credit, BMO Global Asset Management
View Full Profile
As Bob Dylan famously sang, “The times they are a changin’.” But often in times of change, disruption and uncertainty, there can be space for new possibilities.
Where to begin? A global pandemic and the resulting variants; the war in Ukraine; high fuel prices; rising inflation, interest rates, bond yields, cap rates and construction costs; supply chain disruptions; housing affordability; labour shortages; recession fears; flagging consumer sentiment; working from home; the tangible impacts of climate change…. It’s a complex brew of issues, risks and challenges—and perhaps opportunities. But topping the list of concerns for CRE investors is inflation.
Inflation and cap rates
For the current generation of real estate professionals, inflation was just a theory, something to be studied in economics or history class, but hardly something to be concerned about. Then came the repeated economic hits from COVID-19, including supply chain issues; labour, goods and fuel shortages; and now, inevitably, inflation. As the world’s governments aggressively increase interest rates to contain surging inflation, the CRE industry finds itself navigating an unfamiliar landscape.
Inflation leads to higher bond yields, which reduces the risk premium for income producing CRE investments relative to risk-free investments like government bonds, putting upward pressure on cap rates and downward pressure on property values. Current indications from Altus Group suggest CRE investor yield expectations, which are expressed through cap rates, are indeed up approximately 15 bps over last quarter, implying a decline in property values of approximately 3%, and are expected to continue to climb through the remainder of 2022.1
Office and retail cap rates are expected to increase the most due to their typically longer leases, which limits those properties’ ability to increase rents to match inflation. While industrial properties typically have lease durations similar to office and retail, the incredible momentum of Canada’s industrial sector will likely see it continue to outperform the other asset classes and perhaps enjoy some further cap rate compression before levelling off or increasing in late 2022.
Multifamily properties are able to increase rents more frequently, typically annually. This allows multifamily rents to better pace inflation and is why multifamily properties are often described as a good (or at least a better) hedge for inflation. This ability to increase rents more frequently will likely see more modest cap rate increases in the multifamily sector relative to office and retail.
However, cap rates can be “sticky” and usually do not adjust quickly to changing market conditions. More often investment activity slows while buyers and sellers wait for the dust of change to settle. In the near term, expect to see a wider bid-ask spread. And just as residential sales are down 30% to 40% year over year, expect reduced CRE investment activity while the market waits to see if higher cap rates are a blip or the new normal.
Cash flow pressures
Inflation also puts pressure on property cash flows through higher interest rates on property debt and higher nonrecoverable property expenses. Inflation and rising interest rates also increase the likelihood of a recession, leading to additional pressure on property cash flow due to higher vacancies as business tenants delay growth plans or reduce their workforce.
For borrowers with upcoming term loan maturities, today’s higher interest rates can complicate those renewals. Most income producing term loans are sized to generate minimum debt service coverage, or DSC, of approximately 1.25x – a little less for multifamily properties. A $10 million commercial mortgage with a five-year term structured five years ago to generate 1.25x DSC at 3.5% interest and a 25-year amortization would today have an outstanding balance of about $8.6 million. Assuming the same property has a net operating income, or NOI, and a renewal rate of 5.5%, the property would today support a loan of only about $7.3 million to achieve 1.25x DSC at its remaining 20-year amortization, or about $8.2 million if re-amortized to 25 years, requiring a potential equity infusion or additional collateral of around $1.3 million at the remaining amortization, or approximately $400,000 at a 25-year amortization for the loan to renew.
For investors and developers, the rapid emergence of inflation and higher interest rates can challenge deals in flight that were baked with ageing ingredients. An acquisition that looked tasty when it was negotiated six months ago at a 5% cap rate that assumed 3.5% term financing is a lot less palatable if closing today with term debt closer to 5.5%. Likewise, construction of an income producing property that launched two years ago with 75% project financing might require an equity infusion to term-out the construction debt at today’s higher interest rates.
Opportunities ahead
Of course, change also ushers in opportunity. Some of today’s most successful CRE investors got their start capitalizing on the CRE market turbulence of the mid-1990s. Seldom-traded properties might become available as current owners opt to lock-in gains. Some property owners or developers might be receptive to a new partner to bolster their equity. And no doubt war chests are quietly being assembled to capitalize on potential distress situations should inflation remain high and interest rates continue to rise.
These are the times when prudent borrowers will be grateful for a good relationship with their banker. The few current CRE market participants who have lived through volatile times like this know that lenders want their customers to be successful. And that most of all, lenders (and their regulators) don’t like surprises. Lenders respond well to transparency and open communication. It’s best to engage your lender early if you see smoke on the horizon. Ignoring emerging challenges is seldom a good strategy.
Changing times indeed. If Bob Dylan were a CRE investor he might sum things up like this:
Come landlords and lenders throughout the land
And don’t disregard what you didn’t have planned
CRE’s fundamentals are beyond your command
If a deal you are arrangin’
Be careful that castle’s not built upon sand
For the times they are a changin’
1Altus Group
What to Read Next.
Housing Supply & Affordability: How Do We Fix It?
Mike Beg | June 10, 2022 | Commercial Real Estate
Housing prices continue to rise across Canada—including in major cities like Toronto, Vancouver and Montreal—faster and more significantl…
Continue Reading>Related Insights
Tell us three simple things to
customize your experience
Banking products are subject to approval and are provided in Canada by Bank of Montreal, a CDIC Member.
BMO Commercial Bank is a trade name used in Canada by Bank of Montreal, a CDIC member.
Please note important disclosures for content produced by BMO Capital Markets. BMO Capital Markets Regulatory | BMOCMC Fixed Income Commentary Disclosure | BMOCMC FICC Macro Strategy Commentary Disclosure | Research Disclosure Statements
BMO Capital Markets is a trade name used by BMO Financial Group for the wholesale banking businesses of Bank of Montreal, BMO Bank N.A. (member FDIC), Bank of Montreal Europe p.l.c., and Bank of Montreal (China) Co. Ltd, the institutional broker dealer business of BMO Capital Markets Corp. (Member FINRA and SIPC) and the agency broker dealer business of Clearpool Execution Services, LLC (Member FINRA and SIPC) in the U.S. , and the institutional broker dealer businesses of BMO Nesbitt Burns Inc. (Member Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization and Member Canadian Investor Protection Fund) in Canada and Asia, Bank of Montreal Europe p.l.c. (authorised and regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland) in Europe and BMO Capital Markets Limited (authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority) in the UK and Australia and carbon credit origination, sustainability advisory services and environmental solutions provided by Bank of Montreal, BMO Radicle Inc., and Carbon Farmers Australia Pty Ltd. (ACN 136 799 221 AFSL 430135) in Australia. "Nesbitt Burns" is a registered trademark of BMO Nesbitt Burns Inc, used under license. "BMO Capital Markets" is a trademark of Bank of Montreal, used under license. "BMO (M-Bar roundel symbol)" is a registered trademark of Bank of Montreal, used under license.
® Registered trademark of Bank of Montreal in the United States, Canada and elsewhere.
™ Trademark of Bank of Montreal in the United States and Canada.
The material contained in articles posted on this website is intended as a general market commentary. The opinions, estimates and projections, if any, contained in these articles are those of the authors and may differ from those of other BMO Commercial Bank employees and affiliates. BMO Commercial Bank endeavors to ensure that the contents have been compiled or derived from sources that it believes to be reliable and which it believes contain information and opinions which are accurate and complete. However, the authors and BMO Commercial Bank take no responsibility for any errors or omissions and do not guarantee their accuracy or completeness. These articles are for informational purposes only.
Bank of Montreal and its affiliates do not provide tax, legal or accounting advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only, and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, tax, legal or accounting advice. You should consult your own tax, legal and accounting advisors before engaging in any transaction.
Third party web sites may have privacy and security policies different from BMO. Links to other web sites do not imply the endorsement or approval of such web sites. Please review the privacy and security policies of web sites reached through links from BMO web sites.
Please note important disclosures for content produced by BMO Capital Markets. BMO Capital Markets Regulatory | BMOCMC Fixed Income Commentary Disclosure | BMOCMC FICC Macro Strategy Commentary Disclosure | Research Disclosure Statements