Skip to main content
BMO Commercial Bank Close Icon

Select Region / Language

  • US
    • English
  • Canada
    • English
    • Français
BMO Commercial Bank
Commercial Close icon
search icon

Insights

No match found

Industries

No match found

Solutions

No match found

Experts

No match found

Get On Our Email List


Select the business and financial topics of interest to you and sign up to stay current on the latest news
Sign Up Now>
  • Industry Expertise
  • We Can Help
Who We Are
Industry Expertise
We Can Help
Our Bankers
Contact us Get on our email list
BMO Banking

Find

Sign In
Bookmarks 0

Reading List

Email icon
  • Online banking

    Register for online banking with a
    BMO Debit Card or Credit Card


  • BMO InvestorLine
  • BMO Nesbitt Burns
  • BMO SmartFolio
  • BMO Mutual Funds
  • BMO Private Banking
  • BMO Credit Card
  • Online Banking for Business
  • Personal
  • Wealth
  • Business
  • Commercial
  • Capital Markets
Canada EN Contact Us Sign-in
  • Online banking

    Register for online banking with a
    BMO Debit Card or Credit Card


  • BMO InvestorLine
  • BMO Nesbitt Burns
  • BMO SmartFolio
  • BMO Mutual Funds
  • BMO Private Banking
  • BMO Credit Card
  • Online Banking for Business

Select Region

  • US
  • Canada

Select Language

  • English
  • Français

Resources

BMO - Canada logo
search icon
  • Who We Are
  • Industry Expertise
    View all of Industry Expertise
    • Agriculture
    • Auto Dealerships
    • Business Properties
    • Cannabis & Emerging Industries
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Engineering & Construction
    • Franchise Finance
    • Healthcare
    • Manufacturing
    • Media
    • Oil & Gas Services
    • Private Equity Funds/Co-Investments
    • Private Equity Sponsors
    • Professional Services
    • Public Sector
    • Retail & Wholesale Distribution
    • Technology & Innovation
    • Trucking
    • Agriculture
    • Auto Dealerships
    • Business Properties
    • Cannabis & Emerging Industries
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Engineering & Construction
    • Franchise Finance
    • Healthcare
    • Manufacturing
    • Media
    • Oil & Gas Services
    • Private Equity Funds/Co-Investments
    • Private Equity Sponsors
    • Professional Services
    • Public Sector
    • Retail & Wholesale Distribution
    • Technology & Innovation
    • Trucking
  • We Can Help
    View all of We Can Help
    • Addressing COVID-19
    • Asset Based Lending
    • Business Strategy
    • COVID-19 Financial Relief Programs
    • Doing Business Internationally
    • Doing Business in the U.S.
    • Economic Insights
    • Equipment Financing & Leasing
    • Finance Growth
    • Loan Syndication & Agency Services
    • Manage Cash Flow
    • Manage Risk
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Subordinated Debt/Equity
    • Wealth Management
    • Addressing COVID-19
    • Asset Based Lending
    • Business Strategy
    • COVID-19 Financial Relief Programs
    • Doing Business Internationally
    • Doing Business in the U.S.
    • Economic Insights
    • Equipment Financing & Leasing
    • Finance Growth
    • Loan Syndication & Agency Services
    • Manage Cash Flow
    • Manage Risk
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Subordinated Debt/Equity
    • Wealth Management
  • Our Bankers
  • List of bookmarks
    0
    Bookmarks

    Reading List

    Close icon
    Email icon
Navigation Skipped
Navigation Skipped
search icon

Insights

No match found

Industries

No match found

Solutions

No match found

Experts

No match found

Get On Our Email List


Select the business and financial topics of interest to you and sign up to stay current on the latest news
Sign Up Now>
BMO Commercial Banking

Public Policy Changes Needed for Canada to Benefit from Employee Ownership

  • Share this page
    Share this page
    Share page link via email
    Share page link via Facebook
    Share page link via Twitter
    Share page link via Google Plus
    Share page link via Linkedin
  • bookmark

  • print

Worker.
Christine Cooper | March 30, 2022 | Business Strategy
Worker
Christine Cooper | March 30, 2022 | Business Strategy

Published in Financial Post on March 30, 2022.

 

Canada will face an unprecedented transfer of wealth in the next five years as more than three quarters of small- and medium-sized business owners get set to exit their businesses, with billions of dollars of assets changing hands. With the right tools in place, this transition can be a catalyst to broadening Canada’s ownership class and propagating wealth among lower- and middle-income earners.  
 

Canada’s public policy framework for business ownership does not promote alternative structures proven to lead to greater access to the personal wealth and retirement security opportunities that come with ownership. Employee Ownership Trusts (EOTs) have been embraced by the United States and the United Kingdom for their unmatched ability to share the benefits of ownership with those least likely to have it. As a bank that works with employee-owned businesses in the United States and Canada, we at BMO believe Canada needs to adopt policies that make it simpler and more attractive for business owners to sell to their employees, to match the opportunities available in other countries.
 

Employee ownership has a 45-year history in the United States, with employee-owners earning higher wages and enjoying greater job security and more retirement savings than their peers. Recent data from the National Center for Employee Ownership show that employee-owners have a whopping 92 per cent more net wealth than their non-employee-owner counterparts. This trend is especially true for young people, single women, visible minorities and parents raising young children. 
 

Families earning low and middle incomes struggled to make ends meet long before COVID-19. The pandemic has exacerbated this issue and as the cost of living rises, the wealth disparity among Canadians continues to widen. In Canada, the wealthiest one per cent of families hold nearly 25 per cent of the country’s total net wealth, while the bottom 40 per cent hold just over one per cent. Existing options to break this cycle include building savings or taking advantage of RRSP-assisted tax savings. But perhaps the most impactful and accessible to this cohort, with the right tools in place, is employee ownership — where business owners are incentivized to sell to their employees when the time to transition comes, enabling employees to share directly in the success of the company and build wealth over the term of their employment.  
 

One of the better-known examples of an employee-owned company is the American supermarket chain Publix. The chain has 1,200 locations across the Southeastern United States. Employees who work at least 24 hours a week receive shares equivalent to eight per cent of their pay. Upon retirement, employees can sell their shares back to the company. Several long-serving frontline workers have publicly disclosed that they cashed in their shares for over a million dollars when they retired. Overall, EOT participants in the U.S. have double the retirement savings as the average American and are twice as likely to plan to retire before the age of 60. Employee-owners report higher job satisfaction, lower turnover and higher job stability than their non-employee-owner counterparts.  
 

While the personal wealth-building benefits for employee-owners are unmatched, EOTs also offer local economic benefits. Employee-owned businesses are more resistant to economic cycles, insulating communities from downturns and protecting local jobs. Because employee-owners typically live where they work, they are more likely than an external buyer to keep their business operating locally, supporting their communities and providing economic opportunity to local talent. A recent survey by John Zogby Strategies found that having an employee-ownership model in place before the worst of the COVID-19 crisis helped employee-owned businesses not only survive the economic downturn, but also take better advantage of growth opportunities than non-employee-owned counterparts. 
 

For Canada to benefit from employee ownership, public policy change is needed. Today, implementing an employee ownership trust in Canada is difficult and expensive. Current tax treatment significantly reduces the value for both employees and owners, and legislative barriers prevent the U.S. model from being replicated. Drawing on the experience and success of other jurisdictions, we can create a made-in-Canada employee ownership program.  

 
First, we need a legislative framework that makes employee ownership trusts accessible to business owners, with clear rules and a structure that is easy to implement. An “off-the-shelf” corporate form has helped create awareness and accessibility for business owners in the U.S.  
 

Second, we need tax incentives that make employee ownership attractive for all parties. In jurisdictions where EOTs have been successful, governments have married legislative changes with tax incentives. Canada's current tax system makes employee ownership transitions less attractive than other forms of ownership. For Canada to reach the levels of employee ownership the U.S. has experienced and reap the benefits for our local economies, there must be financial incentives for sellers and companies to remain employee-owned over the long term.  
 

Finally, we need oversight, ensuring the public interest is protected as well as the interest of employee-owners. This could include independent and fair corporate valuations before a transaction takes place and rules governing who can participate in an EOT and how they will benefit. 
 

Without these tools in place, we should expect that exiting business owners will follow traditional routes of selling their companies when they retire. Instead, by choosing to encourage alternative pathways like employee ownership, Canada can take advantage of upcoming transitions and broaden the economic benefits for all.  
 

Read more
Christine Cooper, BMO profile photo

Christine Cooper

Executive Vice President & Head BMO Commercial Bank, Canada

Sending message, please wait ...
Send a Message
Send a message to the banker
* Mandatory Fields
Your message has been sent.
The banker will be in contact with you.

Please verify that you are not a robot.

Please do not include personal or confidential information in your message
Send Message

Christine Cooper is responsible for the strategic growth and leadership of BMO Commercial Bank, Canada – a dedicated team of over 2,000 people committed to ...(..)

View Full Profile >

What to Read Next.

Canada can be a Leader on Energy Security

Darryl White | March 22, 2022 | Business Strategy, Oil And Gas Services

Energy

Published in The Globe and Mail on March 12, 2022.   The humanitarian tragedy in Ukraine is devastating. However, the resolve of Ukraini...

Continue Reading>

Related Insights

stock image

Resource Title

Jan 99, 2099 | Primary Category, Secondary Category
short description goes here

Find a Banker

Tell us three simple things to
customize your experience

search 1
search 2
clear selection
clear selection
clear selection
search 1
search 2
search 1
search 2

Commercial

  • Personal
  • Wealth Management
  • Small Business
  • About BMO Harris

Commercial

  • Who We Are
  • Industry Expertise
    • Engineering & Construction
    • Engineering & Construction
    • Agriculture
    • Agriculture
    • Trucking
    • Trucking
    • Public Sector
    • Public Sector
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Auto Dealerships
    • Auto Dealerships
    • Professional Services
    • Professional Services
    • Media
    • Oil & Gas Services
    • Retail & Wholesale Distribution
    • Technology & Innovation
    • Manufacturing
    • Manufacturing
    • Media
    • Oil & Gas Services
    • Retail & Wholesale Distribution
    • Technology & Innovation
    • Private Equity Sponsors
    • Private Equity Sponsors
    • Healthcare
    • Healthcare
    • Franchise Finance
    • Franchise Finance
    • Business Properties
    • Business Properties
    • Cannabis & Emerging Industries
    • Cannabis & Emerging Industries
    • Private Equity Funds/Co-Investments
    • Private Equity Funds/Co-Investments
  • We Can Help
    • Business Strategy
    • Business Strategy
    • Equipment Financing & Leasing
    • Equipment Financing & Leasing
    • Manage Cash Flow
    • Manage Cash Flow
    • Economic Insights
    • Economic Insights
    • Doing Business in the U.S.
    • Doing Business in the U.S.
    • Doing Business Internationally
    • Doing Business Internationally
    • Asset Based Lending
    • Asset Based Lending
    • Loan Syndication & Agency Services
    • Loan Syndication & Agency Services
    • Finance Growth
    • Finance Growth
    • Manage Risk
    • Manage Risk
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Subordinated Debt/Equity
    • Subordinated Debt/Equity
    • Wealth Management
    • Wealth Management
    • COVID-19 Financial Relief Programs
    • COVID-19 Financial Relief Programs
    • Addressing COVID-19
    • Addressing COVID-19
  • Our Bankers
phone hover icon email hover icon phone hover icon email icon phone icon share icon
Contact Us
  • Find a Banker
  • Get on our email list

Follow BMO

  • Phone
  • Book Appointment
  • Find a Branch
  • Report Lost/Stolen Debit Card
  • Report Lost/Stolen Credit Card
  • Modern Slavery Act Statement
  • Privacy
  • Legal
  • Security
  • Careers
  • Investor Relations
  • Accessibility
  • Support
  • Sitemap
  • CDIC Member cdic_canada cdic_canada

BMO Commercial Bank is a trade name of Bank of Montreal.

Please note important disclosures for content produced by BMO Capital Markets. BMO Capital Markets Regulatory | BMOCMC Fixed Income Commentary Disclosure  |  BMOCMC FICC Macro Strategy Commentary Disclosure  |  Research Disclosure Statements

Third party web sites may have privacy and security policies different from BMO. Links to other web sites do not imply the endorsement or approval of such web sites. Please review the privacy and security policies of web sites reached through links from BMO web sites.

Please note important disclosures for content produced by BMO Capital Markets. BMO Capital Markets Regulatory | BMOCMC Fixed Income Commentary Disclosure  |  BMOCMC FICC Macro Strategy Commentary Disclosure  |  Research Disclosure Statements